Grade archive

Graded C

A C on Clad means a mix of accurate and problematic claims — noticeable patterns like one-sided sourcing or missing context — squarely in the middle of the band. The full rubric lives on the methodology page.

Browse other grades: A+ · A · A- · B+ · B · B- · C+ · C · C- · D+ · D · D- · F

21 reports, newest first. Full scorecards unlock with a free CladFacts account.

Grade & lean — See grades free

Nicki Minaj says Democrats dig own grave with Black voters by enforcing conformity

Sep 27, 2026

In this Fox News clip, rapper Nicki Minaj discusses a perceived shift among Black voters away from automatic Democratic loyalty. She claims Democrats treat Black people as unable to think independently or voice concerns without facing smear campaigns and nasty behavior, arguing this intolerance is 'digging their own grave' by alienating smart voters who see through the conditional respect. Minaj emphasizes that no one wants to be told to obey without questions. The short segment features no additional guests or graphics and relies on Minaj's personal observations and celebrity perspective.

▶ Source: Fox News

Grade & lean — See grades free

Hegseth Defends Munitions Command Cuts Amid Iran War Stockpile Concerns

Sep 14, 2026

The segment covers an April 29, 2026 House Armed Services Committee hearing in which Rep. Eric Sorensen (D-IL) questioned Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth on U.S. munitions stockpiles depleted by the Iran conflict and simultaneous workforce reductions at Joint Munitions Command headquarters in Rock Island Arsenal. Hegseth responded that the committee receives weekly classified briefings, there are no operational deficiencies, and a $1.5 trillion defense investment will accelerate private-sector production of Patriots, THAADs, SM-3s and other missiles by 2-4 times while creating American jobs. Sorensen pressed on the reported 58% staff cut at the command, labeling affected workers "redundant" or "surplus," and questioned how munitions oversight would function without the command structure. Hegseth replied that munitions are produced by private industry, not bureaucracies, and slow-moving personnel are replaced to increase speed. Sourcing relied on the live exchange with no external experts or named documents shown; the channel presented Sorensen's concerns as reflective of local workers and neighbors while portraying Hegseth's answers as evasive and raising "even more questions." The throughline emphasized tension between stated munitions priority and headquarters downsizing amid ongoing replenishment needs.

▶ Source: Capitol Hill Insight

Grade & lean — See grades free

Titus Questions Ethics Expert on Truth Social $100k Early-Access Fees and Nevada Data Centers

Aug 29, 2026

The segment shows Rep. Dina Titus (D-NV) questioning an ethics expert during a congressional hearing. Titus links alleged Truth Social monetization via $100,000-per-month early-access subscriptions to broader claims of administration corruption, then shifts to data center impacts on Nevada power bills, tax revenue, and public lands near Boulder City.

▶ Source: Forbes Breaking News

Grade & lean — See grades free

Badenoch defends scrapping net zero target to deliver cheaper electricity

Aug 23, 2026

The Telegraph interview features Kemi Badenoch defending her decision to bar Conservative candidates who support the 2050 net zero target, arguing the party should prioritize fixing real problems over signaling to swing voters in Lib Dem-leaning seats. She rejects supporting net zero 'for the optics' when it harms the environment and insists scrapping the legislation is essential for cheaper electricity, which she says is prerequisite for genuine decarbonization through electrification. The segment draws on a recent Onward think-tank report commissioned by the party that models an alternative 'cheap power' pathway with more gas and nuclear, fewer remote wind farms. No opposing experts or government sources appear; the interviewer presses on candidate bans and voter signaling but accepts the policy intent framing.

▶ Source: The Telegraph

Grade & lean — See grades free

Mike Rogers attacks El-Sayed as extreme, claims flip-flop on union health care

Aug 22, 2026

The short Fox News clip features Republican Senate nominee Mike Rogers criticizing Democratic nominee Abdul El-Sayed as too extreme to win on his beliefs. Rogers references El-Sayed's 2020 book 'Healing Politics' and primary behavior, claiming it alienated UAW workers, pipefitters, and operating engineers over health care, leading to a supposed 'I was just kidding' reversal. Rogers concludes El-Sayed is unfit because voters don't know what he stands for. The segment is a campaign attack with no opposing view or independent analysis.

▶ Source: Fox News

Grade & lean — See grades free

Unifor President Accuses Trump of Seeking to Destroy Canada's Manufacturing Base

Aug 22, 2026

The CBC segment interviews Lana Payne, national president of Unifor and member of Canada's advisory committee on U.S. economic relations, hours after Prime Minister Mark Carney announced the suspension of Canada-U.S. trade talks. Payne confirms that U.S. demands escalated with changing goalposts and interference from the White House, making a deal untenable and risking key manufacturing sectors including autos, steel, aluminum, and heavy trucks. She describes the U.S. approach as lacking unity and ultimately aimed at forcing production shifts south of the border, praises Canadian negotiators for standing firm, and supports retaliatory measures over capitulation. The discussion references recent bargaining with GM in Canada and broader 18-month tensions tied to the USMCA review process. Sourcing relies entirely on Payne's firsthand account from the advisory role and bargaining table, cross-referenced with Carney's public statements and provincial leaders like Doug Ford. No independent U.S. sources or opposing experts are included; graphics are not mentioned. The throughline is Canadian resolve against perceived U.S. aggression amid impending 50% tariffs.

▶ Source: CBC News

Grade & lean — See grades free

DJ recounts Marc Anthony performance and Victoria Beckham dance at 2022 Peltz wedding

Aug 16, 2026

The segment covers details from the April 2022 Brooklyn Beckham-Nicola Peltz wedding reception, focusing on Marc Anthony's performance as a gift from the Beckhams and a later party phase with a revolving stage. It describes Nicola changing into a party dress, the stage reveal, and Marc Anthony introducing Victoria Beckham rather than the bride for a dance with Brooklyn. The reporting draws from accounts by wedding DJ Fat Tony and unnamed attendees, highlighting alleged costs paid by Nelson Peltz and the awkwardness of the moment amid later family tensions.

▶ Source: The Telegraph

Grade & lean — See grades free

Lovett and Favreau Defend Hong's Past Tweets by Attacking Tiffany's Record

Aug 11, 2026

In a Pod Save America segment, hosts Jon Lovett and Jon Favreau discuss the Wisconsin Democratic gubernatorial primary on the eve of the August 11, 2026 vote. They address controversy over frontrunner Francesca Hong's past social media posts calling to cancel Thanksgiving, abolish police and prisons, and related statements. The hosts note she has distanced herself from those views and argue they are being used by Republicans as a distraction. They contrast this with the likely Republican nominee, Rep. Tom Tiffany, listing his past efforts to challenge the 2020 election, claims of massive voter fraud in Wisconsin, support for Trump policies including the Insurrection Act and immigration enforcement, and other positions. The conversation frames the race as a choice between past 'kooky' Democratic statements and substantive Republican extremism.

▶ Source: Pod Save America

Grade & lean — See grades free

Kimmel Guest Host Mocks Trump's Hair, Sleeping at Vaccine Event, and Low Approval

Aug 10, 2026

Anthony Anderson guest-hosted Jimmy Kimmel Live, opening with family banter involving his mother Doris, a comedic appeal to Disney for a Spider-Man role, and a segment on the new Spider-Man: Brand New Day film grossing nearly $2 billion. The show covered "MAGA Olympics" aka Patriot Games announced by Trump for high school athletes with a ban on males in women's sports, Trump's low approval rating, his apparent dozing during a press event on rolling back childhood vaccines, speculation about his newly fuller hair, a Florida naked steakhouse, and a filmed escape room attempt with his mother.

▶ Source: Jimmy Kimmel Live

Grade & lean — See grades free

MS NOW spotlights Trump voter frustration amid Iran war, high gas prices ahead of midterms

Aug 7, 2026

The broadcast discusses poor polling for President Trump and Republicans 88 days before the 2026 midterms, citing a Reuters/Ipsos poll showing Democrats narrowly preferred on the economy and AP-NORC data with ~69-75% viewing the economy as poor. It covers Trump's Punchbowl News interview claiming voter anger targets Republicans in Congress, not him personally, and features interviews with Trump voters expressing stress over gas prices, inflation, inability to save, and the ongoing US-Iran war. The segment highlights Democratic momentum in Senate races in Georgia, Iowa, North Carolina, and Texas, plus an upset Republican primary loss in Tennessee's 5th District. It concludes with an interview with Democratic nominee Chaz Molder.

▶ Source: MS NOW

Grade & lean — See grades free

Duckworth Accuses VA Secretary Collins of Veteran Service Disruptions in Senate Hearing

Aug 6, 2026

The video breaks down a Senate Veterans' Affairs Committee hearing in which Sen. Tammy Duckworth confronted VA Secretary Doug Collins over the effects of early 2025 mass terminations of roughly 2,400 probationary VA employees, many hired after the PACT Act expanded eligibility. Duckworth presented constituent cases of delayed benefits, six-week mental health appointments, canceled prescriptions, and long record backlogs, arguing these stemmed from indiscriminate DOGE-led cuts that also affected Veterans Crisis Line support and training staff. Collins acknowledged some errors, stated that most affected staff (including 24 erroneous VCL notices) were reinstated, emphasized that no frontline crisis responders were let go, noted protected healthcare positions, and offered to assist with her cases while attributing some delays to DoD records issues. The coverage relies primarily on hearing excerpts, Duckworth's prepared remarks, and a quoted April 2025 letter from Collins on VCL staffing. It features no independent experts or Collins' later testimony on backlog reductions. The throughline is the tension between workforce reductions for efficiency and the risk of service interruptions for veterans.

▶ Source: THE FLOOR REPORT

Grade & lean — See grades free

Zack Polanski backs Jason Arday after Cambridge plagiarism probe prompts resignation

Aug 6, 2026

The Sky News segment discussed Green Party leader Zack Polanski's continued support for Cambridge sociology professor Jason Arday, one of 16,000 signatories to a solidarity letter after Arday resigned amid a university investigation into his PhD thesis and qualifications. Correspondent Grant Stoddard outlined Arday's rapid rise as the university's youngest Black professor at age 37 in 2023, his claimed charity fundraising of £5.5 million through ultra-running feats, and questions over plagiarism in his PhD and personal achievements. Arday's resignation statement, published via the Good Law Project, described the experience as beyond scholarly criticism and taking a profound toll on him and his family, without directly admitting the allegations. The broadcast noted prior investigations cleared him but new information prompted Cambridge's review, alongside a forthcoming memoir detailing his autism diagnosis and late literacy.

▶ Source: Sky News

Grade & lean — See grades free

O'Reilly blames ICE discipline lapses for protests; Cuomo challenges criminal alien counts and body cam history

Jul 22, 2026

The NewsNation segment features Bill O'Reilly discussing ICE operations, protests, and allegations of misconduct under the Trump administration. He compares ICE issues to Secret Service failures at Butler, PA, and defends aggressive enforcement amid high migrant volumes. Chris Cuomo pushes back on statistics, body camera mandates, and sourcing from groups like Human Rights Watch. The exchange covers funding disputes from prior administrations and debates over transparency.

▶ Source: NewsNation

Grade & lean — See grades free

Roy pushes permanent border bill; Raskin condemns ICE tactics in House hearing

Jul 21, 2026

The clip shows Rep. Chip Roy (R-TX) delivering an opening statement advocating the 'permanent Trump Secure Border Act,' which codifies changes to asylum, detention, unaccompanied minors, family detention, visa overstays, and parole. He recounts decades of unaddressed loopholes across administrations and names victims of crimes by illegal immigrants. Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-MD) responds by criticizing recent ICE operations, citing shootings and deaths in custody, lack of oversight, and calling the bill partisan enforcement-only legislation.

▶ Source: Times Of India

Grade & lean — See grades free

Mary Miller Grills Medical Deans on Uterus Definition, DEI Compliance in House Hearing

Jul 16, 2026

The YouTube clip from The Financial Express features Rep. Mary Miller (R-IL) at the July 14, 2026, House Education and Workforce Committee hearing 'Training Activists, Not Physicians: The Impact of DEI on Medical Schools.' Miller questioned deans from UCLA, UCSF, and University of Illinois College of Medicine on inclusive terminology in curricula (e.g., 'pregnant people' vs. 'pregnant women,' not assuming gender identity), alleged non-compliance with Trump executive orders eliminating federally funded DEI, and whether someone with a uterus can not be a woman. Witnesses responded by referencing compliance with state and federal law, comprehensive evaluations, and the need to treat diverse patients. The segment cuts to Rep. Lucy McBath (D-GA) defending diversity language and highlighting racial health disparities in maternal mortality, cancer, and chronic disease. Sourcing relied on quoted course materials and school websites with no slides or full documents shown; witnesses were primarily medical school leaders.

▶ Source: The Financial Express

Grade & lean — See grades free

Stanton faults Trump Iran policy amid Hormuz shipping uncertainty

Jul 12, 2026

Bloomberg interview with Rep. Greg Stanton (D-AZ) on foreign affairs and transportation committees. Segments cover the status of the Strait of Hormuz amid US-Iran strikes, criticism of Trump administration Iran policy including a recent deal and JCPOA withdrawal, the death of Sen. Lindsey Graham, Ro Khanna's West Bank detention incident, and the decision not to renew USMCA.

▶ Source: Bloomberg Podcasts

Grade & lean — See grades free

FRANCE 24 Covers Ronaldo's Response in Portugal World Cup Win

Jun 24, 2026

The FRANCE 24 English segment addresses Cristiano Ronaldo responding to critics following Portugal's 5-0 World Cup victory over Uzbekistan. Portugal had previously drawn their opener, prompting questions about the veteran forward. The provided transcript contains only music cues, indistinct sounds, and no substantive dialogue or narration. No specific guests, graphics, or sourcing details are evident from the material. The report aligns with broader coverage of Ronaldo scoring twice to make history at age 41.

▶ Source: FRANCE 24 English

Grade & lean — See grades free

Germany Rail Halt from GSM-R Glitch: DW News Review

Jun 23, 2026

The DW News segment covers a nationwide halt of German trains on Tuesday evening due to a technical issue. It includes brief passenger interviews describing trains stopping abruptly, a communication error, and contingency plans like booking buses. The second paragraph notes the sourcing relies on on-the-ground passenger quotes with no named experts or graphics referenced in the provided transcript.

▶ Source: DW News

Grade & lean — See grades free

DW News covers Laredo, Texas highway plane crash

Jun 17, 2026

The DW News segment reports on a small business jet that crashed on a highway in Laredo, Texas, late on June 16, 2026. The brief clip includes audio of an emergency call noting loss of communication with the aircraft and efforts to rescue those on board. Five of six people survived with one fatality reported; bystanders assisted first responders at the scene. The sourcing draws from on-scene audio, police statements, and eyewitness accounts typical of breaking news coverage of the incident.

▶ Source: DW News

Grade & lean — See grades free

Schumer Pushes Senate Amendment to Block $1.8B DOJ Anti-Weaponization Fund

Jun 16, 2026

The clip shows Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer previewing a vote on an amendment to permanently ban a roughly $1.8 billion 'Anti-Weaponization Fund' created by the DOJ as part of a settlement in President Trump's IRS lawsuit over leaked tax returns. Schumer labels it a 'MAGA slush fund' and 'sweetheart deal' enabling tax issues for Trump and family, attacks Republicans for not blocking it, and references Todd Blanche's assurances.

▶ Source: Forbes Breaking News

Grade & lean — See grades free

Trump DOJ Indicts 8 U-Mich Pro-Palestinian Activists on Conspiracy Charges

Jun 12, 2026

The segment discusses federal indictments unsealed June 10, 2026, against eight individuals tied to University of Michigan pro-Palestinian activism from 2023-2024 protests. It covers conspiracy to transmit threats via social media and telecommunications, prior unsuccessful state prosecutions by AG Dana Nessel after local prosecutor Eli Savit declined, and political context including regents pressure and elections. The broadcast features attorney Amy Doukoure from CAIR Michigan, references the 63-page indictment's language on vandalism and symbols, and argues the charges target protected speech like divestment demands rather than specific credible threats.

▶ Source: Breaking Points

← Graded C+ · Graded C- →