Gutfeld likens Jason Arday scandal to George Floyd death, blames woke enablers
Source: Fox News · All Fox News reports
Unlock the full scoreboard
Letter grade, factuality, lean, and rationales — free with registration. No card required.
See grades free How grading works
Already have an account? Sign in. The full report below is free to read.
Embed this grade
Disagree with this grade or political lean?
Flagging is open to every reader with a free account. Sign in or create one to dispute this report.
Topics in this report
Summary
The segment opens with Greg Gutfeld's monologue mocking various news items before focusing on the death of Jason Arday, Cambridge's youngest Black professor. Gutfeld details Arday's extensive fabrications — including running 30 marathons in 35 days (some with a broken leg), raising $5 million for charity, surviving brain tumors and testicular cancer, being illiterate until 18, and multiple other claims — plus plagiarism in his academic papers. He argues the academic and media establishment enabled these lies out of racial virtue-signaling, leading to Arday's resignation amid scrutiny, subsequent suicide, and mourners blaming racism. Gutfeld draws a parallel to George Floyd, claiming his death was attributed to racism rather than fentanyl overdose, heart issues, or behavior, and asserts that 'woke' views of Black people as perpetual victims are the real racism.
Editorial Assessment
The broadcast accurately reports many of Arday's specific false claims, which were exposed by investigations from outlets like The Times, Telegraph, and researcher Nathan Cofnas, showing plagiarism in his PhD and papers as well as contradicted personal stories. However, it omits that Cambridge faced legitimate pressure over its lack of Black professors and that some initial inquiries cleared aspects of his work before further evidence emerged. The Floyd comparison selectively emphasizes contributing factors like fentanyl levels (verified at potentially fatal amounts in some documents) while downplaying the medical examiner's official ruling of homicide via restraint and neck compression. Viewers miss broader context on how DEI initiatives can sometimes bypass rigorous vetting, leading to backlash, and how media frenzy on both sides amplified the story. The panel's discussion on accountability and 'mean but honest' criticism leans heavily into conservative tropes about liberal hypocrisy without engaging counter-evidence that intense public scrutiny, including threats and identity-based attacks, contributed to Arday's mental health crisis. Overall, it prioritizes cultural grievance over nuanced examination of academic integrity failures on all sides.
Key Moments
Arday claimed to run 30 marathons in 35 days, some with a broken leg, raised $5M for charity, survived two brain tumors and testicular cancer, was illiterate until 18.
Multiple outlets including NYT, Atlantic, and Guardian reported these as fabricated or embellished claims contradicted by evidence and acquaintances.
Arday plagiarized tons of academic work; an open secret at Cambridge until exposed by another professor analyzing his papers.
Nathan Cofnas published evidence of extensive plagiarism in Arday's PhD and papers; Cambridge later investigated and Arday resigned.
Crowd mourning Arday blames racism for his death, just like with George Floyd whose cause was racism not lethal fentanyl or heart failure.
Floyd's official autopsy ruled homicide from cardiopulmonary arrest complicating law enforcement subdual, restraint, and neck compression; fentanyl and heart disease were significant contributing conditions but examiner testified they were not the direct cause.
What is racist is what the woke think of Black people — that they need no experience or skills and are permanent victims.
This is Gutfeld's opinion framing DEI efforts; no evidence presented beyond the Arday case, and critics argued the intense scrutiny was racially motivated.
Cambridge and media indulged Arday's delusions because he was a trophy 'magical minority' making white libs feel virtuous.
NYT reported Cambridge hired him despite underqualification under diversity pressure and ignored warnings; however, Arday was also celebrated for genuine work in sociology of education before scandals.
Notable Concerns
- Heavy partisan framing equates legitimate plagiarism probes with racism denial while ignoring Cambridge's documented oversight failures in hiring.
- Analogy between Arday's self-fabricated lies and George Floyd's death is strained and omits full autopsy context and Chauvin conviction.
- Mourners' racism claims are mocked without noting Cambridge chancellor's public criticism of a 'racist feeding frenzy' in coverage.
Sources Consulted
- Professor’s Death Leaves Behind Hard Questions for Cambridge on Race and Hiring
- The Truths That Failed Jason Arday
- Cambridge chancellor criticises 'racist feeding frenzy'
- Jason Arday, youngest Black professor at Cambridge, found dead at 41 after resignation
- Heart disease, fentanyl contributed to George Floyd's death but were not main cause, medical examiner says
- Playbooks, plagiarism and a pig's head: new claims surrounding Cambridge professor Jason Arday
- Despite Other Factors, Police Caused Floyd's Death, Medical Examiner Testifies