Grading Content & Exposing Bias

Grade

Toast data ranks Delaware top tipper at 21.4%, California lowest at 17.1%

Source: ABC News · All ABC News reports

Unlock the full scoreboard

Letter grade, factuality, lean, and rationales — free with registration. No card required.

See grades free How grading works

Embed this grade

Paste this on your site or blog — the badge links readers to the full report (grade values stay in the image, same policy as our share cards).

CladFacts grade badge for: Toast data ranks Delaware top tipper at 21.4%, California lowest at 17.1%
Disagree with this grade or political lean?

Flagging is open to every reader with a free account. Sign in or create one to dispute this report.

Topics in this report

Summary

ABC News reported on a new Toast restaurant-trends release that ranks states by average tipping percentage at restaurants using the company's payment platform. The broadcast highlighted the six most generous states (Wyoming, Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, West Virginia, New Hampshire) all above 20% and identified California and Washington as the lowest at a little over 17%, naming Delaware the single best at 21.4%. It presented the list as a straightforward consumer-interest story without additional analysis or interviews.

The sourcing was limited to the single Toast report; no external experts or competing data sets were cited. The segment used on-screen graphics to display the state list and percentages.

Editorial Assessment

The claims are factually accurate and line up directly with Toast's published Q2 2026 state-by-state table. Viewers receive a clear snapshot of credit-card tipping variation but miss important context: the data cover only Toast-platform transactions, exclude all cash tips, and calculate "overall" as total tips divided by gross processing volume rather than a simple average of full-service and quick-service checks. High-tipping states tend to allow a lower tipped minimum wage while California and Washington require full minimum wage plus tips, a structural factor that likely influences customer behavior but was not mentioned. The short format therefore presents real numbers without the caveats that would let audiences interpret them as a pure measure of generosity.

Key Moments

verified

Wyoming, Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, West Virginia and New Hampshire all tip on average more than 20%

Matches Toast Q2 2026 overall figures: WY 20.3%, OH 20.3%, IN 20.4%, KY 20.3%, WV 20.7%, NH 20.5% (all above 20% in contemporaneous releases; slight quarterly variance possible).

verified

California and Washington State average a little over 17%

Toast reports CA 17.1% and WA 17.6% overall for the referenced period.

verified

Delaware is the best state for wait staff at 21.4% average tip on credit cards

Exact match to Toast's latest overall figure of 21.4% for Delaware.

verified

Toast restaurant payment company released a list of the country's most and least generous tippers

Directly from Toast's quarterly Restaurant Trends Report published September 2026.

Notable Concerns

  • Omission of methodology limitations including exclusion of cash tips
  • No discussion of tipped-minimum-wage differences across states

Sources Consulted

  1. Restaurant Tipping Trends | Data by Toast
  2. Which states tip the most? Data reveals the best and worst
  3. A New Report Reveals the States That Tip the Most
  4. Average Tip Percentage in America [2026 Toast Platform Data]
  5. Liberal Strongholds Home To America’s Stingiest Tippers
  6. Stingy tippers, steep taxes: California and Washington state anchor the bottom of the tipping charts
  7. Is tipping down? Why the gold standard of 20% tips may be slipping