US aid to Israel hits historic levels under Trump as polls show public support eroding
Source: Al Jazeera English · All Al Jazeera English reports
Why this grade: Graded B-: most specific claims (Biden bomb pause, Trump Knesset pardon remark, continued high aid levels) verified by multiple sources; however, headline claim of 'record high' public support is directly contradicted by 2025-2026 polling data showing record lows in favorability and sympathy.
Why this lean: Heavy emphasis on civilian deaths, protest movements, Biden's frustration with Netanyahu, generational shift away from Israel, and use of terms like 'cracked' support; sources and framing align with critical coverage of Israeli actions typical of Al Jazeera.
Disagree with this grade or political lean?
Flagging is open to every reader with a free account. Sign in or create one to dispute this report.
Topics in this report
Summary
The segment reviews US policy toward Israel from October 2023 onward. It notes immediate strong Biden support including a visit to Tel Aviv and high military aid, followed by growing domestic protests, a policy rift over civilian casualties, Biden's May 2024 pause of 2,000-pound bomb shipments, and Netanyahu's address to Congress. It then covers the transition to Trump, who criticized Netanyahu as an obstacle to a hostage deal and publicly urged a pardon for him during an October 2025 Knesset speech, yet continued and in some cases accelerated aid flows. The report concludes that while official policy remains steadfast, public opinion has shifted markedly, reflected in polls and street protests, with politicians adjusting positions.
Sourcing relies on named historical events, direct quotes from Biden, Netanyahu and Trump, street footage of protests, and a closing stand-up by correspondent Alan Fisher at the White House. No new anonymous officials or fresh data graphics are introduced; the narrative draws on well-documented moments across two administrations.
Editorial Assessment
The broadcast accurately captures the tension between consistent elite and governmental support for Israel and declining public sentiment, especially among Democrats and younger Americans. Major factual claims hold up: Biden did pause large bomb shipments in 2024 over Rafah concerns; Trump did call for Netanyahu's pardon in the Knesset and at times pressed for hostage-focused pauses in fighting; aid has remained at or above the baseline $3.8 billion FMF level with substantial supplementals under both presidents. However, the title and opening assertion that US support is 'at record high' is unsupported and contradicted by contemporaneous polling from Pew, Gallup, and the Chicago Council on Global Affairs showing favorability at record lows (37-44%) and sympathy tilting toward Palestinians for the first time. Viewers may come away believing governmental policy is increasingly isolated without sufficient emphasis on persistent Republican support or the scale of supplemental appropriations. The framing leans into criticism of Israeli conduct and US complicity while underplaying Israel's security rationales and Hamas's role.
Key Moments
Biden blocked shipment of 2,000 bombs in May 2024
Confirmed by AP, Axios, and Times of Israel reporting; pause targeted 1,800 2,000-lb and 1,700 500-lb bombs over Rafah concerns; some later resumed.
Trump issued direct order for Israel to stop bombing Gaza to free hostages safely
Trump posted on Truth Social in October 2025 demanding Israel halt bombing after partial Hamas acceptance of his peace plan; Israel reduced offensive operations.
Trump intervened in Israeli domestic affairs urging pardon for Netanyahu in October 2025 Knesset address
Multiple outlets (Bloomberg, Times of Israel, Jerusalem Post) confirm Trump told President Herzog 'why don’t you give him a pardon' during the speech.
Aid to Israel continued at historic levels: $4 billion in 2025, $2.8 billion in September, including the 2,000 bombs Biden blocked
Baseline ~$3.8B FMF continued; supplementals brought totals far higher ($17.9B first year of war); Trump administration did release paused large bombs and approved billions more in sales.
America's public support for Israel has cracked
Pew 2026: 60% unfavorable (up from 42% in 2022); Gallup 2026: more sympathize with Palestinians (41%) than Israelis (36%); Chicago Council: record-low 44° thermometer rating.
Notable Concerns
- Title and lead claim of 'record high' support directly at odds with multiple 2025-2026 polls showing record lows
- Limited context on why aid continued (Iran threats, shared intelligence, long-standing MOU)
- Omits that some polls still show majority support for Israel's right to exist and defend itself
Sources Consulted
- American Favorability of Israel Drops to Record Low
- US views of Israel, Netanyahu more negative in 2026, especially among young adults
- Israelis No Longer Ahead in Americans' Middle East Sympathies
- Israel-Hamas war: Biden warns US won't supply weapons for Rafah attack
- Trump Lobbies for Netanyahu Corruption Pardon in Knesset Speech
- U.S. has given at least $21.7B in military aid to Israel
- Trump tells Israel to stop bombing Gaza after Hamas partially accepts his peace plan
- US military aid to Israel 2025