Pennsylvania Measles Outbreak Hits 1,500 Cases as Midwives Seek Vaccine Authority
Source: NBC News · All NBC News reports
Unlock the full scoreboard
Letter grade, factuality, lean, and rationales — free with registration. No card required.
See grades free How grading works
Already have an account? Sign in. The full report below is free to read.
Embed this grade
Disagree with this grade or political lean?
Flagging is open to every reader with a free account. Sign in or create one to dispute this report.
Topics in this report
Summary
The NBC News segment reports on Pennsylvania's ongoing measles outbreak, the largest in decades, centered in Lancaster County among largely unvaccinated Amish communities. It follows midwife Roberta Devers on house calls to pregnant women, many of whom contracted measles leading to miscarriages, and highlights her inability under state law to administer MMR vaccines despite growing requests from families. Interviews include an affected Amish mother, a pediatrician treating severe infant cases, and national context on falling vaccination rates.
Sourcing draws from Pennsylvania Department of Health data, the midwife's firsthand accounts, an NBC News/Stanford University investigation into kindergarten immunization, and a Texas public health official. The report notes RFK Jr.'s 2021 speech in the area downplaying measles risks and connects it to local hesitancy, while noting DOH has administered over 10,000 vaccines but access remains challenging for remote families. It ends with discussion of potential U.S. loss of measles elimination status.
Editorial Assessment
The broadcast is largely accurate and well-sourced with primary state data and on-the-ground reporting that humanizes the outbreak's impact on pregnant women and infants. Claims about case counts, deaths (including two babies), vaccination decline, and legal barriers for traditional midwives align closely with Pennsylvania DOH updates and recent reporting. Viewers get a clear picture of how low uptake in religious communities, exacerbated by misinformation, drives severe outcomes that are preventable with MMR (97% effective with two doses).
Missing context includes that traditional midwives lack standardized medical training, prompting opposition from groups like ACOG to expanding their scope to vaccines; any change requires legislative action, not just DOH approval. The segment could note broader U.S. trends (5,000+ national cases) and that >99% of PA cases are in unvaccinated individuals, strengthening the prevention message. Framing leans toward urgency around vaccine access and skepticism but avoids exaggeration. Overall, it effectively illustrates the vaccine divide without major distortions.
Key Moments
Pennsylvania has reported more than 1,500 measles cases and six deaths, including two babies.
PA DOH data as of Nov 2026 shows 1,467-1,505 cases across 45 counties and six confirmed measles-associated deaths, nearly all unvaccinated; two infant deaths reported.
Lancaster County vaccination rates dropped from 94% in 2019 to 87.6% now; three-quarters of U.S. counties below 95% herd immunity threshold.
Confirmed by NBC/Stanford investigation and state data; Lancaster kindergarten MMR at 87.6% for 2025-26 school year, national decline documented.
Midwife has seen dozens of pregnant women with measles, some ending in miscarriage; she cannot vaccinate despite requests because traditional midwives cannot administer vaccines under PA law.
Direct from midwife Roberta Devers' account in NBC article; PA DOH confirms law requires legislative change, as it constitutes practicing medicine.
RFK Jr. spoke in Lancaster in 2021 claiming without evidence that measles shots are harmful.
Video of 2021 speech shows him downplaying measles severity, calling it treatable with chicken soup/vitamin A, and criticizing vaccines; linked to local hesitancy.
U.S. could lose measles elimination status soon, with PAHO meeting this week.
PAHO commission met in Nov 2026 to review; experts widely expect loss of status due to sustained transmission since 2025.
Notable Concerns
- Slight discrepancy in reported case total (>1,500 in transcript vs. official 1,467-1,505 as of early November)
- Limited discussion of training and safety concerns around allowing unlicensed traditional midwives to administer vaccines
Sources Consulted
- Pennsylvania Department of Health Measles Update - Sixth Death Confirmed
- NBC News: She’s delivered 2,000 babies. The measles outbreak changed her mind about vaccines
- Vaccine opposition has brought measles roaring back in America – NBC News/Stanford Investigation
- US measles cases top 5,000 as PAHO weighs elimination status
- PA measles cases surpass 1,500, state health department says
- Why Pennsylvania’s measles outbreak changed this midwife’s views
- RFK Jr. 2021 Lancaster Speech and Measles Claims