Slotkin and Kelly mark anniversary of video urging troops to refuse illegal orders
Source: The Hill · All The Hill reports
Unlock the full scoreboard
Letter grade, factuality, lean, and rationales — free with registration. No card required.
See grades free How grading works
Already have an account? Sign in. The full report below is free to read.
Disagree with this grade or political lean?
Flagging is open to every reader with a free account. Sign in or create one to dispute this report.
Topics in this report
Summary
Sens. Elissa Slotkin and Mark Kelly, joined by other Democratic veterans, held a press event marking one year since releasing a video reminding military and intelligence personnel to refuse illegal orders and uphold the Constitution. They described the video as a simple restatement of law but said it prompted Trump to repeatedly call for their investigation, arrest, and hanging on social media, leading to death threats, swatting, FBI/DOJ probes, and a failed February grand jury attempt by U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro to indict them for sedition. Slotkin recounted personal impacts including bomb threats and her father's swatting; Kelly discussed Hegseth's censure and attempt to demote his retired Navy rank for defending the Constitution. They referenced Trump's past suggestion (per Esper's book) of shooting Lafayette Square protesters in the legs and criticized lack of congressional oversight on military actions.
Editorial Assessment
The segment accurately reports the existence and general content of the 2025 video, Trump's strong rhetorical response labeling it sedition, and the unsuccessful criminal pursuit by the Trump DOJ. Viewers miss critical context: the lawmakers provided no specific examples of illegal orders in the video, and Slotkin later stated she was unaware of any from Trump. The framing casts the video as purely defensive while critics viewed it as preemptively encouraging disobedience and eroding military discipline. Personal stories of threats are presented without independent verification of scale or direct causation from Trump's posts versus general political rhetoric. References to Esper's account of the 2020 'shoot in the legs' comment are verified but from a prior administration and used here to imply a pattern. Overall, the one-sided presentation and selective emphasis on intimidation over the legal and military propriety debate skew perception toward viewing Trump as authoritarian without counter-evidence on grand jury standards or UCMJ accountability for retired officers.
Key Moments
Trump tweeted over a dozen times calling for the lawmakers to be investigated, arrested, and hanged after the video
Trump labeled the video 'seditious behavior punishable by death,' called for prosecution, and shared messages including 'HANG THEM GEORGE WASHINGTON WOULD' on Truth Social.
The video prompted DOJ and FBI investigations, culminating in Jeanine Pirro bringing the group before a grand jury in February to indict for sedition
U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro's office pursued the case; grand jury unanimously rejected indictment for lack of probable cause.
Trump suggested shooting unarmed protesters in the legs at Lafayette Square; Esper and Milley pushed back on the illegal order
Confirmed in Mark Esper's 2022 memoir 'A Sacred Oath'; occurred during 2020 George Floyd protests.
Hegseth censured Kelly, is trying to demote him and strip his earned Navy rank and pension for saying he would defend the Constitution
Hegseth issued censure and initiated review of Kelly's retired rank/pay in January 2026, citing violations of UCMJ for statements on the video and later comments.
Thousands of threats, including bomb threats at Slotkin's house and swatting of her father in his last month of life, resulted directly from Trump's statements
Slotkin reported threats and earlier swatting incidents occurred; direct causal link to Trump's specific posts versus broader political climate is self-reported and not independently corroborated here.
Notable Concerns
- Heavy reliance on self-reported personal threats and anecdotes without corroborating details or alternative sourcing
- Omission that the original video implied domestic threats from the Trump administration without naming illegal orders, later walked back by Slotkin
- Partisan framing equating Trump's heated rhetoric and failed prosecution attempt with direct incitement and authoritarianism
Sources Consulted
- Watch: Slotkin, Kelly mark one year since ‘illegal orders’ video sparked Trump backlash
- Slotkin Statement After Trump Again Called for Her to be Prosecuted Over 90-Second Video
- Prosecutors fail to secure indictment against 6 Dem lawmakers
- Jeanine Pirro's office shelves pursuit of Democrats over social video
- Trump suggested shooting DC protesters in the legs, according to ex-Defense Secretary Mark Esper
- Hegseth censures Kelly after senator urged troops to defy illegal orders
- One year later, former national defense Dems stand by illegal orders video
- Fact Check: Six Members Of Congress Did NOT Say Military Service Members Should Refuse Legal Orders