Bulwark mocks Mullin's 'SI' outage theory as anonymous tech guess
Source: The Bulwark · All The Bulwark reports
Unlock the full scoreboard
Letter grade, factuality, lean, and rationales — free with registration. No card required.
See grades free How grading works
Already have an account? Sign in. The full report below is free to read.
Disagree with this grade or political lean?
Flagging is open to every reader with a free account. Sign in or create one to dispute this report.
Topics in this report
Summary
The Bulwark segment critiques Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin's Fox News interview in which he attributed a string of recent U.S. technical outages—including a nationwide FAA ground stop, Microsoft disruptions, and banking issues—to 'SI' (super intelligence), relaying an unnamed tech industry contact's view that advanced AI self-fixing code is overwhelming legacy systems not designed to handle its speed. The hosts highlight Mullin's 98% certainty that no cyberattack is involved, his refusal to name the source (while confirming it is not Elon Musk), and the recency of the conversation (about three hours prior). They contrast this with preliminary government assessments pointing to a malfunctioning router at an Arkansas radar/radio site during routine maintenance.
Editorial Assessment
The broadcast accurately captures Mullin's statements but presents them in a highly derisive tone that emphasizes the speculative and anonymous nature of his source while downplaying his alignment with CISA assessments ruling out a cyberattack. Viewers miss fuller context: the FAA has publicly attributed the November 13 ground stop to a newly installed router in El Dorado, Arkansas, that flooded the network with excessive connection attempts (roughly 1,000 every 4-5 seconds), affecting 17 of 22 en route centers; separate Microsoft and Chase issues were traced to software bugs, not AI. The framing encourages skepticism of the Trump administration's handling of infrastructure incidents but does not explore whether Mullin's broader reassurance about unrelated incidents holds or if legacy system fragility is a legitimate concern. Overall, it is entertaining commentary that holds up on facts but leans heavily on ridicule rather than balanced analysis.
Key Moments
Mullin is relaying an anonymous tech expert's 98% certain view that 'SI' (super intelligence) is causing the outages by overwhelming old systems with self-fixing code
Matches Mullin's Fox News interview with Sean Hannity on Nov. 16-17, 2026; he used the exact phrasing and house-change-order analogy.
Government preliminary assessments point to malfunctioning routers connected to routine maintenance at a radar station in Arkansas
FAA, Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy, and multiple outlets (WSJ, NYT, TechSpot) identified the El Dorado, Arkansas router upgrade by L3Harris as the trigger for the nationwide FAA ground stop on Nov. 13.
Mullin is getting cues from some random guy in tech and presenting a 'xerox of a xerox' guess
Mullin presented it as one informed opinion after consulting CISA, which also saw no cyber indicators; the segment does not note that Mullin said the incidents appear individually unrelated.
The whole thing is unbelievably nuts and not reassuring
Opinion commentary; no evidence presented that Mullin's no-cyberattack stance is incorrect, and officials have consistently ruled out attacks on the FAA incident.
Notable Concerns
- Heavy use of sarcasm and loaded phrases that signal partisan disdain rather than neutral analysis
- Limited discussion of the distinct causes of the multiple outages, which could leave viewers thinking all were addressed by the same Arkansas router explanation
Sources Consulted
- DHS' Markwayne Mullin suggests AI could've caused outages at airlines, banks
- How one malfunctioning router in Arkansas grounded every flight in America last week
- Markwayne Mullin blasted for pushing theory from ‘one guy’ that AI is behind recent string of tech outages
- Mullin Suspects AI Is Behind System Meltdowns, Explains How
- FAA identifies router as cause of nationwide ground stop
- Mullin blames tech outages on ‘SI’
- DHS Says AI Could Be Responsible For Outages