Biden Memoir Recounts Merkel's Private Frustrations With Trump's Mood Swings and Putin Fascination
Source: DW News · All DW News reports
Unlock the full scoreboard
Letter grade, factuality, lean, and rationales — free with registration. No card required.
See grades free How grading works
Already have an account? Sign in. The full report below is free to read.
Disagree with this grade or political lean?
Flagging is open to every reader with a free account. Sign in or create one to dispute this report.
Topics in this report
Summary
The DW News segment reports on excerpts from Joe Biden's new memoir 'Promise Me, America,' in which he recounts private conversations with former German Chancellor Angela Merkel about her difficult relationship with Donald Trump. It highlights Merkel's reported frustrations with Trump's refusal to shake her hand, emotional 'mood swings' over facts, and fascination with Vladimir Putin and autocratic leaders. The broadcast reviews archival footage of their tense public encounters and interviews Jeffrey Rathke, president of the American-German Institute, who notes the accounts echo Merkel's own memoir and reflect broader policy clashes on defense spending, energy, migration, and trade.
Rathke discusses how Trump's first-term criticisms of Germany have continued but become less personalized in the second term, contrasts the Merkel handshake moment with more confrontational recent diplomacy like the 2025 Zelensky meeting, and assesses limited personal common ground despite Merkel's efforts to engage via issues like workforce training. The segment explores whether Merkel's presence today would alter dynamics given Germany's increased defense role post-Ukraine invasion.
Editorial Assessment
The broadcast is factually reliable in summarizing Biden's memoir, which matches excerpts reported by Newsweek and other outlets. Claims about Merkel's views are corroborated by her 2024 memoir 'Freedom,' where she describes Trump operating on an 'emotional level' versus her 'factual' one, his fascination with Putin, and the calculated handshake refusal. Viewers miss that Biden's retelling is secondhand recollection from 2021 conversations, not verbatim transcripts, and that The New Yorker review notes the memoir often footnotes such anecdotes to prior public reporting. The framing emphasizes Trump's unconventional style as disruptive to transatlantic norms while downplaying policy grievances like German NATO spending shortfalls that Rathke acknowledges. Rathke provides measured expert context as a longtime transatlantic diplomat, avoiding overt partisanship, but the overall narrative reinforces a narrative of Trump as erratic and Merkel as steady without exploring Trump's perspective on Merkel's 2015 migration policies or Nord Stream decisions.
Key Moments
Merkel told Biden she was frustrated by Trump's refusal to shake her hand, emotional mood swings rather than facts, and fascination with Putin and autocrats.
Directly matches excerpts from Biden's 'Promise Me, America' reported by Newsweek; closely parallels Merkel's own descriptions in her 2024 memoir 'Freedom' of 'emotional' vs 'factual' levels and Trump's fascination with autocrats.
Merkel and Trump had fundamentally different worldviews on immigration, trade, and the transatlantic relationship, visible in public moments like the handshake snub.
Well-documented in both leaders' memoirs, contemporaneous news footage from the March 2017 White House visit, and Rathke's analysis; Trump repeatedly criticized Merkel's migration policy and German trade/defense imbalances.
Trump's first-term grievances with Germany (low defense spending, Russia energy dependence, migration) have continued into his second term but are less personally aimed at the current German leader.
Rathke's assessment is plausible but omits specific current tensions or data on Germany's post-2022 defense increases (now Europe's largest spender); Merkel's Nord Stream policy remains a point of ongoing criticism.
Merkel tried to build personal rapport with Trump by involving Ivanka Trump on workforce training but found limited success, opting for interest-based diplomacy.
Rathke's recollection not directly corroborated in the reviewed sources or memoirs; Merkel's book emphasizes business-like approach but does not detail Ivanka channel prominently in available excerpts.
Notable Concerns
- Reliance on private, one-sided recollections from Biden without contemporaneous documentation or Trump-side response
- Limited exploration of substantive policy disagreements (e.g., German defense spending below 2% NATO target during Merkel's tenure)
Sources Consulted
- Biden Reveals What Angela Merkel Really Thought of Donald Trump
- Angela Merkel offers views on Putin, Trump, Ukraine in long-awaited memoirs
- Merkel: I mistook Trump for ‘someone completely normal’
- Joe Biden’s Memoir “Promise Me, America” Shows a Man in Denial
- Germany's Merkel recalls Putin's 'power games' and contrasting US presidents in her memoirs
- The With-Limits Partnership – AGI
- About AGI – American-German Institute