Berman Defeats Steil After Attacking His 62.5% Portfolio Outperformance
Source: Political Integrity Project · All Political Integrity Project reports
Unlock the full scoreboard
Letter grade, factuality, lean, and rationales — free with registration. No card required.
See grades free How grading works
Already have an account? Sign in. The full report below is free to read.
Disagree with this grade or political lean?
Flagging is open to every reader with a free account. Sign in or create one to dispute this report.
Topics in this report
Summary
The clip is a campaign advertisement from Mitchell Berman, an emergency room nurse challenging incumbent Rep. Bryan Steil (R-WI) in Wisconsin's 1st District. Berman cites personal experiences with patients unable to afford medications or skipping care due to work demands, contrasting this with Steil allegedly enriching himself through stock trading. The ad highlights Steil's strong 2025 portfolio performance and his sponsorship of a congressional stock-trading reform bill portrayed as inadequate.
Sourcing relies on public financial disclosures, Unusual Whales rankings, and Wisconsin Watch reporting on net worth growth. No named experts or guests appear; it is a direct-to-camera personal appeal ending mid-sentence on beating Steil. The throughline is ethics in Congress and prioritizing working families over personal gain. Steil ultimately lost the 2026 race to Berman, flipping the long-held Republican seat.
Editorial Assessment
The claims hold up well against primary disclosures and independent trackers: Steil's portfolio did rank fourth in 2025 outperformance per Unusual Whales, and his net worth rose substantially amid a strong market. Viewers miss that much of the growth reflects broad market gains in funds like Vanguard growth and mid-cap holdings rather than rapid individual stock trading, and Steil had divested financial-sector stocks upon joining relevant committees. The ad's framing as "enriching himself" and the bill as a "sham" leans heavily on Democratic critiques (e.g., Sen. Tammy Baldwin's comments) that it allows holding existing stocks and omits broader reforms like divestment requirements. This selective emphasis could skew perceptions toward viewing all congressional investing as corrupt without noting that blind trusts or full bans remain elusive across parties. Overall quality is typical for campaign media — accurate on sourced numbers but partisan in tone and omissions.
Key Moments
Steil had the fourth most successful portfolio in Congress last year, beating the market by 62.5% and doubling his net worth.
Confirmed by Unusual Whales 2025 congressional trading report and Wisconsin Watch analysis of disclosures showing net worth rising from ~$812k in 2018 to ~$1.9M by 2024/2025.
Steil introduced the sham stock trading bill last cycle.
Steil introduced the Stop Insider Trading Act in 2026; it passed the House (232-198) but was blocked in the Senate. Critics called it a sham for allowing members to retain existing holdings, requiring only advance notice of sales, and not covering crypto or prediction markets.
Patients unable to afford medications or signing out against medical advice to avoid missing work while congressman enriches himself.
Anecdotal from Berman's nursing experience; no specific data or link to Steil's actions provided in the clip. Broader healthcare affordability issues exist but are not directly tied to Steil's portfolio.
We need to ban buying/selling individual stocks for Congress and include the executive branch.
This matches Berman's stated platform and common reform proposals; Steil's own bill focused on purchase bans and sale notifications but faced criticism for not going far enough or covering the executive fully.
Notable Concerns
- Partisan campaign ad format presents one side without rebuttal or full legislative context on the bill's passage in the House and specific loophole debates.
- Omits that many of Steil's reported gains derive from long-term mutual fund holdings and overall market performance rather than active day trading.
Sources Consulted
- Commentary: Congressional stock trading is not a good issue for Bryan Steil
- How much the wealth of Wisconsin’s congressional delegation has changed
- Bryan Steil Stock Tracker | Portfolio & Net Worth
- Bryan Steil (R-WI) Stock Trades & Portfolio
- Mitchell Berman defeats Bryan Steil in Wisconsin's 1st District
- Steil Introduces Legislation to Ban Congressional Stock Trading
- Top Congress Stock Traders 2025
- Berman defeats Steil to flip Wisconsin’s 1st Congressional District